When you have money to invest, knowing how to grow it wisely makes all the difference. The choice between a ULIP top-up and a new SIP has some important differences in their costs and benefits, how the investments are managed, and how easily you can get your money out. These differences make it tricky to compare them properly. Therefore, deciding between the two needs to be carefully thought about.
Let us explore the main things that set these two investment approaches apart when you're in this situation, to help you make a clearer decision.
Key Takeaways
|
Before we draw the conclusion about which is better for your surplus funds, ULIP or SIP, let's understand what each entails.
A ULIP insurance plan is a hybrid financial product that offers life insurance cover and investment. A portion of your premium pays for the life coverage and other plan charges, while the remaining amount is used as an investment in funds of your choice. It can be in equity, debt, or a balanced portfolio, much like mutual funds.
The value of your investment is represented by 'units', which fluctuate based on market performance. They typically come with a lock-in period, usually five years, before which withdrawals are restricted or not allowed. Many individuals use an online calculator to project potential returns based on assumed growth rates and to understand the impact of various charges.
An SIP is not a product itself, but a method of regular investments in mutual funds. You commit to fixed amount investment at regular intervals (weekly, monthly, quarterly) into a chosen mutual fund scheme. SIPs are popular for promoting disciplined investing.
The investment benefits are generally from rupee cost averaging. In addition, the power of compounding over the long term also helps grow the investment. They are purely investment vehicles and do not inherently come with an insurance component.
A ULIP top-up is an additional, lump-sum investment you can make into your existing ULIP insurance plan over and above your regular premium payments. Think of it as injecting extra capital into your current investment and insurance framework. Most insurers allow top-ups, often with certain conditions regarding minimum/maximum amounts and frequency.
A crucial point to note is that each top-up premium might also have its own mini lock-in period (often the standard 5 years from the date of the top-up). Otherwise, it might follow the main policy's lock-in, depending on the insurer's terms. It's also common for top-ups to primarily go towards the investment component, with minimal or no increase in the sum assured unless specifically paid for.
An OTP has been sent to your mobile number
Sorry ! No records Found
Thank You for submitting the response, will get back with you.
Thank You for submitting the response, will get back with you.
When you have surplus funds, deciding between topping up your existing ULIP insurance plan or starting a fresh SIP involves weighing several factors, including:
| Feature | ULIP Top-up | New SIP (Mutual Funds) |
|---|---|---|
Upfront Charges | May have low or nil premium allocation charges in newer ULIPs. | No entry loads. |
Flexibility in Charges | Varies by insurer and top-up structure. Some top-ups are cost-efficient. | Direct plans have lower expense ratios than regular plans. |
Exit Load | Usually, there is no exit load, but it is subject to ULIP lock-in rules (5 years). | Exit loads may apply if redeemed within a specific time (e.g., 1 year). |
Lock-in Period | 5 years. | No mandatory lock-in, except for tax-saving equity linked savings scheme or ELSS (3 years). |
Investment Transparency | Use ULIP calculator to estimate costs and returns from top-ups. | Transparent NAV (Net Asset Value), expense ratios disclosed by fund houses. |
Insurance Benefit | This includes mortality benefits as part of the ULIP structure. | No insurance coverage is included. |
Suitability | Suitable if you want insurance plus investment, and the top-up has minimal charges. | Suitable if you prefer pure investment with low ongoing costs. |
Verdict | Cost-effective if allocation charges are low or nil, and better for insurance-linked investment. | More cost-effective long-term for pure investment needs, especially in direct plans. |
| ULIP Top-Up | New SIP | Consideration |
|---|---|---|
Existing ULIP provides life cover. Top-up may slightly enhance the sum assured, but is mainly for investment enhancement. | SIPs are pure investment vehicles and offer no life insurance component. | If you already have sufficient life cover, SIP’s lack of insurance isn’t a drawback. If you’re underinsured, a ULIP top-up may offer a slight, cost-efficient enhancement. |
| ULIP Top-Up | New SIP | Insight |
|---|---|---|
Limited to the fund options offered within your existing ULIP insurance plan. Typically includes equity, debt, balanced, and liquid funds. Fund switching is allowed. | Offers access to a vast range of mutual fund schemes across asset classes, providing deeper diversification and customisation. | SIPs offer superior investment flexibility and broader diversification, making it easier to tailor portfolios to your exact risk profile and financial goals. |
| ULIP Top-Up | New SIP | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
ULIPs have a 5-year lock-in. Top-up premiums also usually follow this lock-in from the top-up date. Partial withdrawals are allowed post-lock-in, with conditions. | Most open-ended mutual funds allow redemption on any business day (except ELSS, which has a 3-year lock-in). Funds are usually credited within days. | SIPs offer higher liquidity, ideal if funds may be needed within 5 years. For long-term goals, ULIP lock-ins may not be restrictive and could align with growth objectives. |
| ULIP Top-Up | New SIP | Insight |
|---|---|---|
Premiums (including top-ups) qualify under Section 80C (up to ₹1.5 lakh) if the annual premium is less than or equal to 10% of the sum assured. Maturity is free from taxation under Section 10 (10D) if conditions are met. For policies post-Feb 1, 2021, with a total annual premium of more than ₹2.5 lakh, maturity proceeds are taxed like equity mutual funds. | Only ELSS SIPs qualify for Section 80C (up to ₹1.5 lakh). Other SIPs don’t offer upfront tax deductions. LTCG (long-term capital gain) on equity funds (held for more than 1 year) is taxed at 10% beyond ₹1 lakh, and STCG (short-term capital gain) at 15%. Debt funds are taxed differently, with recent indexation changes. | ELSS SIPs are ideal for straightforward 80C tax saving. ULIPs may offer broader benefits, but newer, high-premium policies require careful tax evaluation, especially for long-term planning and post-2021 tax implications. |
ULIP insurance plan with an annual premium of over ₹2.5 lakh will be considered as LTCG and taxed at 12.5%.
Source: Taxgyany
An investment calculator, especially a ULIP calculator, can be a resourceful tool in this decision-making process. The following are the different ways to use an online ULIP investment calculator based on your situation:
Ultimately, the choice between a ULIP top-up and a new SIP for your surplus funds isn't black and white. It hinges on factors like your individual financial situation, goals, risk appetite, current insurance coverage, etc. One more important factor that influences the choice is your satisfaction with your existing investment.
At Canara HSBC Life Insurance, we ensure that your investment stays safe. As a ULIP insurance plan customer, we keep your long-term financial growth and protection at the core of everything we do. In addition to smart premium top-up options, you can experience continuous integrated life cover to protect your loved ones while your money grows.
Whether you're topping up or starting anew, we have everything for your peace of mind. Accomplish your financial goals confidently with us.
SIPs can offer lower costs and more fund choices, potentially leading to better pure investment returns. Evaluate charges and flexibility carefully before deciding on your approach.
ULIPs have fund management and mortality charges. SIPs have an expense ratio. Top-ups might have low initial charges, but SIPs (direct) can be cheaper overall.
ULIP top-ups typically share the 5-year lock-in of the base plan. SIPs (excluding ELSS) generally offer better liquidity, allowing quicker access to your invested funds.
Yes, ULIPs inherently include insurance. Top-ups mainly boost investment but are part of an insured plan. SIPs are pure investments with no life cover included.
Both offer Section 80C benefits. ELSS SIPs are solely for tax-saving investment. ULIPs offer broader benefits, but recent high-premium policies have complex tax rules.
ULIPs offer limited fund choices within one plan. SIPs provide vast options across many fund houses. Prioritise based on your desire for diversification and control.
Yes, a ULIP calculator helps project growth with a top-up. However, compare its cost structure carefully against a standalone SIP for a fully informed investment decision.
Disclaimer - This article is issued in the general public interest and meant for general information purposes only. The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Canara HSBC Life Insurance Company Limited or any affiliated entity. We make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the blog or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained in the blog for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. You should consult with a qualified professional regarding your specific circumstances before taking any action based on the content provided herein.
Canara HSBC Life Insurance offers online ULIP plans that blend life insurance protection with investment growth, helping you build wealth while securing your family's future.
