When it comes to building a reliable retirement corpus, every rupee invested today can decide the comfort and security of your later years. There are so many types of investments, and each has a unique risk and return profile. So, how do you make the best choices? Will you choose the secured future of a government-assured pension system, or do you want to take a calculated risk in market-linked investments with an expected higher return?
Well, the answer lies in carefully doing the math between available options. The launch of the new contribution slab of ₹6,500 per month under the Atal Pension Yojana has received quite a fanfare in the retirement planning sphere. Meanwhile, small-cap Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) have been providing excellent long-term earnings to those who can withstand volatility with enough patience and risk-taking skills.
This blog will analyse each of these two alternatives, crunch the numbers over a 30-year time horizon, and understand if life insurance can be an effective part of a sensible retirement planning strategy.
Key Takeaways
|
In order to dive into the comparisons, we should first have some knowledge about the foundations of the APY and why it has taken the likes of risk-averse investors. Atal Pension Yojana is a state-sponsored pension plan to provide a regular income source to the workers of the unorganised sector, and particularly to those professionals who receive salaries.
In declaring a new slab of ₹6,500 monthly contributions, users of the scheme can now invest more with an aim of earning a bigger pension. It is especially attractive to people who care about a guaranteed income after retirement and do not wish to expose their money to market fluctuations.
An OTP has been sent to your mobile number
Sorry ! No records Found
Thank You for submitting the response, will get back with you.
Let us explore its structure in detail.
The serious gap that the Atal Pension Yojana was seeking to solve was the absence of formal pension coverage among millions in the unorganised sector. It has grown to offer the promise of stability to salaried workers in their quest for secure sources of income after retirement.
The addition of a monthly slab of ₹6500 is a major improvement over APY because now subscribers can aspire to a greater pension range than earlier. This will add more appeal to the scheme for middle-income earners who can pay more into the scheme and demand better protection against inflation during retirement.
Understanding who can enrol in APY and how the benefits are structured is essential before committing to the scheme. These details help investors assess whether the ₹6,500 slab aligns with their retirement goals and financial capacity.
Small-cap SIPs are those that invest in shares not ranked in the top 250 by market capitalisation. Such businesses often have the potential for high growth, yet their performance may be unstable in the short term. Reinvesting returns over a long time horizon (for example, 20 to 30 years) due to the compound effect can result in the generation of large wealth, so long as the investor is able to withstand the fluctuations in the market between the initial investments and the reinvest to reproduce the effect.
Learning the Small-Cap SIP Potential through various horizons
Small-cap SIPs, compared to APY, do not have government support but provide flexibility, liquidity, and potential to offer better returns in relation to fixed-income products over a long time. Tax in equity mutual funds is also different, wherein beyond the ₹1 lakh on gross returns in a financial year, this number is charged at 10% on Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG).
Investment Horizon | Average Annualised Returns* | Volatility Level | Best-Case Scenario | Worst-Case Scenario |
5 Years | 14%-18% | High | Significant gains | Sharp losses |
10 Years | 12%-16% | Moderate-High | Strong growth | Flat returns |
20-30 Years | 10%-14% | Moderate | Substantial corpus | Inflation impact |
*According to the historical data of AMFI, historical returns do not guarantee future returns.
The following is a fictitious example of the two investment alternatives on a 30-year scale, assuming that the investor is aged 30 with an investment amount of ₹6,500 a month.
Assumptions:
Parameter | APY (₹6,500 Slab) | Small-Cap SIPs |
Monthly Contribution | ₹6,500 | ₹6,500 |
Tenure | 30 Years | 30 Years |
Total Invested | ₹23.4 lakh | ₹23.4 lakh |
Estimated Corpus at 60 | N/A (Pension Scheme) | ₹2.15 crore |
Monthly Pension (Today’s Value) | ₹25,000* | Market-linked withdrawals |
Risk Level | Very Low | High |
Liquidity Before 60 | No | Yes |
Taxation on Returns | Pension taxable | LTCG @ 10% beyond ₹1 lakh gains |
*Illustrative estimation based on higher contribution benefits under APY.
As of April 2025, the Atal Pension Yojana has 7.65 crore subscribers and a ₹45,975 crore corpus, with women forming nearly half the base.
Source: ET
Although the statistics demonstrate a definite contrast between Atal Pension Yojana and small-cap SIPs. The lesson here is not to choose one or the other; and to construct a plan of action that can deal with both safety and growth.
The purposes of both products are different as retirement planning is concerned. In APY, there is a kind of absolute income security, and in SIPs, wealth maximisation is the target. The combination of both offers the advantage of mitigating risks of both longevity, inflation, and being able to pay with currency that is at a later date.
Diversification is to make sure there is no complete reliance on a single asset classification in terms of retirement income. A secure pension is capable of meeting the basic needs costs, whereas market-linked investments ensure protection against inflation and maintenance of the cost of living. Such a mixture lowers the chances of outliving the money during old age.
The two instruments serve different purposes, namely, fixed income provides stability, and equity promises higher returns.
Comparative Role in Retirement Planning:
Parameter | APY (Fixed Income) | Small-Cap SIPs (Equity Growth) |
Stability | High | Low-Moderate |
Growth Potential | Low | High |
Inflation Hedge | Low | High |
Liquidity | None till maturity | High |
Risk | Minimal | High |
Even the best investment schemes can be disrupted if the primary income earner passes away unexpectedly. This is why life insurance, especially term plans, comes into the picture here.
For example, in case you are contributing to APY and SIPs, Term Plans by Canara HSBC Life Insurance will make sure these contributions do not stop in your absence. Furthermore, you get a guaranteed pension and the equity corpus for your family.
A term insurance calculator is a useful online tool that helps you determine how much coverage you need based on your income, lifestyle, and family’s needs.
The above calculation and illustration of figures are indicative only and not on actual basis.
The Atal Pension Yojana and its new ₹6500 slab are government-guaranteed post-retirement income schemes that provide maximum security. In contrast, small-cap SIPs may be riskier, but can generate substantial wealth over time. This does not mean that there is only a yes or no answer, and mixing the two into an effective retirement planning framework may afford you stability and growth.
This would require investing all your monthly savings in both APY in terms of fixed income and SIPs in terms of market growth in small-caps, and then securing the entire plan with a good term insurance cover. In this manner, you will be relieved because you know that your retirement will not only be safe but also successful.
The higher ₹6,500 monthly contribution allows investors to secure a larger pension payout upon retirement, making APY more attractive for those who can commit more each month and want a guaranteed income.
Small-cap SIPs offer higher long-term growth potential but carry greater short-term risk, while APY provides a stable, government-backed pension with no market volatility.
Yes, combining APY for guaranteed income and SIPs for market-linked growth can create a balanced retirement plan that offers both safety and inflation-beating returns.
Over 30 years, small-cap SIPs typically build a larger corpus due to compounding and higher growth rates, while APY focuses on fixed monthly pension payouts rather than corpus accumulation.
Life insurance ensures that planned contributions to APY and SIPs can continue even in the event of the investor’s death, safeguarding the retirement plan for dependents.
Disclaimer - This article is issued in the general public interest and meant for general information purposes only. The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Canara HSBC Life Insurance Company Limited or any affiliated entity. We make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the blog or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained in the blog for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. You should consult with a qualified professional regarding your specific circumstances before taking any action based on the content provided herein.
We bring you a collection of popular Canara HSBC life insurance plans. Forget the dusty brochures and endless offline visits! Dive into the features of our top-selling online insurance plans and buy the one that meets your goals and requirements. You and your wallet will be thankful in the future as we brighten up your financial future with these plans.
